Special Guest Stars Bradley Whitford as Pence Humphreys Nancy Travis as Winifred "Winnie" Humphreys Guest Stars Jasmine Batchelor as Detective Tonie Churlish Erin Anderson as Counselor April Andrews Rigo Garay as Sacrilege J.C. MacKenzie as Counselor Richard Pace Co Starring Erin Quill as Doctor Adrienne Wright Michael Varde as Pence Humphreys (age 20) Pat Patterson as Mrs. Bailey Julie Ryan as Virginia Wise Michael Basile as Detective Vic Garrett Eric Munro Schwan as Kevin Wise Holly Hinchliffe as Winifred "Winnie" Humphreys (age 20) Marlana Cay Baker as Winifred "Winnie" Olsen (age 10) Noah Feldman as Pence Humphreys (age 10) Andrew Lincoln as Doctor Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration