Guest Stars Alex Brightman as Herbie Hambright Mackenzie Astin as Jonathan Pritchard Ruffin Prentiss as Young Harold Cooper Tia Dionne Hodge as Foreperson Brenda Crawley as Jury Member Jose Soto as Lu Fernan Lee Sellars as Warden Nathan Klau as Benny Seaver Kevin Craig West as Juror Four Robert Neary as Lawrence Nelson / The Postman Asmeret Ghebremichael as Gina Abbott Co Starring Sami Bray as Agnes Keen Lance Roberts as Eugene Campos Mike Massimino as Truck Driver Jesus A. Del Rosario Jr. as Prisoner Jose A. Diaz as Table Mate Justin Crowley as SWAT Officer