Guest Stars Connie Shi as Detective Violet Yee Milica Govich as Judge Leanne Dreben Alayna Hester as Lily Cosgrove Justina Machado as Lauren Whitmer Casey Simpson as Aaron Cole Gary Lee Mahmoud as Alan Meyerson Anna Rizzo as Julia Cosgrove Kylie Victoria Edwards as Sophia Elliot Ilana Becker as Heather Elliot Gabriel Gutiérrez as Layton Miller Co Starring Daniel Danielson as MLI Detective Kimberly Fairbanks as Judge Maria Cruz Siliek Wynder as Thick Dude Joseph Will as Jerome Elliot John Pigate as Lawrence Cole Lil Malinich as Cynthia Cole Benjamin J. Young as Cooper Walsh Nicole Van Giesen as Nicole Geller Brittane Rowe as Foreperson Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration