Special Guest Stars Michael Cassidy as Charlie Hogan Guest Stars Alice Greczyn as Mandy Ignacio Serricchio as Luis Dave Franco as Zachary Todd Elaine Hendrix as Elyse Valencour Keith Bogart as Alex Co Starring Stacy Barnhisel as Geraldine Ty Vincent as Charlie's Teammate Jah Shams as Will's Teammate Brent Keast as The Priest Amber Krzys as Jill Johnny Warren as The Lifeguard