Guest Stars Wendy Crewson as Mary Dove Shaw Lee Tergesen as Ashton Shaw Ashley Nicole Roxburgh as Jesse Bowers Matthew Nelson-Mahood as Young Russell Shaw Alison Araya as Sarah Riley Link Baker as Mark Riley Jeremy Jones as Jack Horvath Paniz Zade as Officer Amini Kahn Mattia Castrillo as Gilbert "Gil" Brown Prestyn Bates as Young Colter Shaw Co Starring Garfield Wilson as Fred Dalias Blake as State Investigator Sean Owen Roberts as Milton Patrick Bahrich as Desk Sergeant Arianna McGregor as Patty Nicole Anthony as Ms. Hicks Colm Hill as Derek Nemo Cartwright as Big Burly Cop Oscar Chark as Craig Riley Aggie Bell as Dorian Shaw Zia Newton as Counter Worker Frankie Kletas as 4-Year-Old Girl Stephen Hooper as Edward "Eddie" Brown