Guest Stars Jennifer Tilly as Tiffany Valentine Lara Jean Chorostecki as Charlotte Collins K.C. Collins as Coop Jackson Kelly as Grant Collins Callum Vinson as Henry Collins Franco Lo Presti as Hicks Gil Bellows as Warren Pryce Michael Therriault as Spencer Rhodes Ayesha Mansur Gonsalves as Melanie Spiegel August Winter as Secret Service Agent Rachael Ancheril as Erica Dorsett Alex Paxton-Beesley as Gretchen Nia Vardalos as Evelyn Elliott Sarah Sherman as Annie Gilpin Co Starring Jacob Breedon as Chucky Nick A. Fisher voices Good Guy Doll Matt Willis as Frack Duane Kip Brown as Frick Mal Dassin as Eli Griffin Wurster as Joseph Collins Mich Ward as Atrium Guard Bessie Cheng as Agent Mac Barnes Wilfred Lee as Security Guard Adam Growe as Reporter Moni Ogunsuyi as Mia Cunningham Troy James as Creepiest Clown Ever Philip Honey as Butler Liz Der as Inmate #2 Lili Connor as Inmate #1