Guest Stars Spencer MacPherson as Jacob Landry Remy Smith as Jacob Landry Jefferson Brown as Colton Landry Alex Hook as Young Kat Landry David Webster as Teen Elliot Marnie McPhail as Rita Richards Samora Smallwood as Monica Hill Samuel Braun as Teen Nick Siddharth Sharma as Teen Brady Watson Rose as Susanna Augustine Kris Holden-Ried as Thomas Coyle Rob Stewart as Sam Bishop Alex Eling as Noah Leblanc Monique Jasmine Paul as Teen Monica Kerry James as Nick Nck Name as Masked Partygoer #1 Brendan Cox as Masked Partygoer #2