Guest Stars Melissa Villaseñor voices Pencil Thomas Lennon voices Paper's Brain Fred Tatasciore voices Burly Pirate Fred Tatasciore voices Pirate Captain Ron Funches voices Tough Bee Goon 1 Ron Funches voices Tortoise Debra Wilson voices Sleeping Skydiver Debra Wilson voices Skeleton Debra Wilson voices Saleswoman Debra Wilson voices Crazy-Eyed Pirate Thomas Lennon voices Parrot Thomas Lennon voices Paper's Bladder Melissa Villaseñor voices Pencil Judge #1 Melissa Villaseñor voices Pencil Judge #2 Melissa Villaseñor voices Pencil Judge #3 Carlos Alazraqui voices Parrot Pirate Carlos Alazraqui voices Hieronymus Bosch