Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Abigail Hawk as Det. Abigail Baker Gregory Jbara as DCPI Garrett Moore Robert Clohessy as Sid Gormley Steven R. Schirripa as Anthony Abetemarco Stephanie Kurtzuba as Captain Paula McNichols Annabella Sciorra as M.E. Faith Marconi Deisy Patiño as Christina Dominguez Zani Jones Mbayise as Akeelah Stallings Rigo Garay as Freddie Dominguez Summer Crockett Moore as MaryEllen Duggar Jason Tottenham as Det. Wesley Pierre Kristolyn Lloyd as Officer Margot Matthews Maria-Christina Oliveras as Det. Johnson Gene Gillette as Det. Larkin Carolee Carmello as Gerri Mazullo Co Starring Darik Bernard as Officer Irving Justin S. Kirkland as Officer Burgess Talia Cuomo as Katie McNichols Elijah J. Carlos as Eli Stallings J. Paul Nicholas as Landlord Morpheus Peters as Student #1 Keisha T. Fraser as Teacher Maria M. Diaz as Neighbor #1 Sarah Joyce as Neighbor #2 Jay Santiago as Abner