Guest Stars Molly Price as Detective Donnelly Fredric Lehne as Lieutenant Dave Noonan Adam Kaplan as Rob Greg Hildreth as Lewis Blecher Jr. Keegan-Michael Key as Ashton Hayes Geneva Carr as Poppy Hayes Jocelyn Webb as Nora Hayes Nick Fondulis as Derek Co Starring Alex Wyse as Cooper Jahir Hipps as Hip-Hop Tour Guide Tavia Hunt as Valencia Kate Mulligan as Janine Amie MacKenzie as Club Member 2 Brent Harris as Club Member 1 Amber Ardolino as Capri Kaitlyn Boyer as Waiter
