Guest Stars Fredric Lehne as Lieutenant Dave Noonan Micaela Diamond as Detective Edwards Ajay Naidu as Martin Wali Elizabeth Lail as Quinn Powers Eric William Morris as Josh Johnson Madeline Seidman as Mimi Bladmire Co Starring Allison McKay as Agnes Alex Webb as Investor Ayana Workman as Ellen Davis Alex Bartner as Chad John El-Jor as Employee with Wet Mop Haircut Geena Quintos as Lina Rodd Cyrus as Toby