Guest Stars Joel David Moore as Colin Fisher Katheryn Winnick as Hannah Burley B.J. Britt as Clinton Antonio Sabàto Jr. as Terror Gina LaPiana as Josephine Lisa LoCicero as Janine Genaro Jack Donner as Crusty Jonathan Kowalsky as Peppy Dio Joey Russo as Frankie Costello Anthony Pumilio as Richie "The V" Genaro Liana Mendoza as Marie Galasso