Guest Stars Joel David Moore as Colin Fisher Billy F. Gibbons as Himself Charlie Weber as Nolan Samantha Shelton as Antonia "Toni" Lawrence Samantha Quan as Misty Clemmons Emily Wilson as Emma Jon Curry as Kevin Braley Joshua Dov as Wes Ott Cynthia Sophiea as Mrs. Allen Theresa June-Tao as FBI Tech Kylie Sparks as Jill