Guest Stars Greta Titelman as Gina Bowen Yang as Dodo the Elf Sandra Caldwell as Attorney Sydnee Washington as Vicky Ikechukwu Ufomadu as Oscar Jeter Rivera as Michael Eudora Peterson as Amina Natasha Lyonne as Susannah Dylan O'Brien as Dustin Bernardo Velasco as Edwin Kim Petras as Telemarketing Mermaid #1 Ana Fabrega as Trish Spike Einbinder as Carl Brittany Carney as Mona Thomas Rachielle as Young Julio Princess Nokia as Telemarketing Mermaid #2 Rachel Dratch as Rellany Emma Stone as Genevieve Rosie Perez as Bianca Patti Harrison voices Deedra James Scully as Brandon Sam Taggart as Bryce Francesca D'Uva as Zappos Employee Cole Escola as Dina Richard Perez as Donnie Katharine Cullison as Carl's Mom
