Special Guest Stars Sarah Michelle Gellar as Tanya Martin Guest Stars Brittany Allen as Laura Moser Aaron Jennings as Clark Sanders Raquel Justice as Sofia Jasper Lewis as Doris Morgan Eli Sherman as Little Dexter London Thatcher as Nicky Spencer Jeff Daniel Phillips as Levi Reed Isaac Gonzalez Rossi as Gio Martino Carlo Mendez as Hector Estrada Randy Gonzalez as Santos Jimenez Roberto Sanchez as Tony Ferrer Co Starring Xander Mateo Delatorre as Young Brian Victoria Martzloff as Tiffany Chandler Lovelle as Daniela Paola Andino as Jen Murray Gray as Officer Cruz Lauren Neal as Coach Pino Moses Jones as Officer Muszynski Shawn Law as Sheriff Michael Jaworski as Officer Jablonski Jamal Lloyd Johnson as Muscle Man Nicole French as Officer Franklin Tara Robinson as Cashier Haley Powell as Annemarie Scott Reynolds as John Wayne Gacy Kyle F White as Ed Gein Osama Awadalla as David Berkowitz
