Guest Stars Miriam Silverman as Gretchen Reagan Heather Lind as Kat Resnick Matthew Rauch as Gordy Hughes Rebecca Naomi Jones as Suzanne Haber Jordan Gelber as Paul Levitt Anna Osceola as Maggie Haber Jennifer Mudge as Julie Sperling Dave Quay as Dom Resnick Manu Narayan as Hari Sahni Ramin Karimloo as Bruce Emerson Robert Bagnell as Brad Sperling Stephanie Kurtzuba as Diane Miller Robert Eli as Peter Miller Kitty Hawthorne as Olivia Cross Daniel Dale as Jake Weston Corbin Bernsen as Jack Bailey Co Starring James Snyder as Toby Edward Chin-Lyn as Josh Lori Funk as Mary Sarah Thompson as Susie Emerson Daniel Cosgrove as Monty Reed Joe Lanza as Cop Bhavesh Patel as Lance McRae John Brodsky as Finance Guy Mohammad Saleem as Finance Guy Dan Madonia as Cashier