Guest Stars Ethan Phillips as John J. Murray Brenda Strong as Mel Gaynor-Randle Missi Pyle as Bartender Antonio Sabàto Jr. as Jorge Raya Meddine as Claire Co Starring Jay Ali as Brock Bernadette Gambino as Police Tech Deborah Stewart as Intense Woman Kimberly Willess as Katie Gaynor-Randle Melinda Ratner as Mary Anne