Guest Stars Steven Ogg as Blaine Abel Conrad Coates as Mayor Ken Dillisch Katharine King So as May Tao Hudson Wurster as Cooper Cypress Mark Little as Deputy Brent Carlisle Kaleb Horn as Rhodey Rasch Glen Gould as Deputy J.P. Brissett Gianpaolo Venuta as Professor Aaron Weimer Lenore Zann as Jeannie Gorski Nathan Dales as Deputy McCray Paige Evans as Carla Maia Jae Bastidas as Kay Mathurin Lanette Ware as Nella Gia Sandhu as Nithiya Weimer Nicky Guadagni as Arlene Stankiewicz Co Starring Aryelle Morrison as Deputy Rogers Kara Wooten as Clarice Katie Stolp as Reporter Amy Rivard as Nurse Becky Matthew Lee as Orderly #1