Guest Stars Chosen Jacobs as Jamie Martin Hunter Emery as Deputy Walter Flynn Branton Box as Sheriff Jonny Baskin Karen Rodriguez as Deputy Wanda Salazar Paul Teal as Pastor Pete Lightfoot Abigail Rhyne as Nina Jason Davis as Reverend Clint Thompson Co Starring Madison Wolfe as Abby Jackson Emmett Moss as Jack O'Neil Nick Hagelin as Deputy Chet Ledoux Jill Jane Clements as Memaw Nicole SamuelWashington as Joyce Scott N. Stevens as Mel Osborn
