Guest Stars Laura Marcus as Mollie Garfield Dylan Hughes as Jim Garfield Jr. David Nykl as Levi Morton Anders Olof Grundberg as Abram Garfield Alfie Tempest as Irvin Garfield Archie Fisher as Joe Brown Andrew Hefler as Tom Platt Jack Alldridge as Harry Garfield Tuppence Middleton as Kate Sprague Paula Malcomson as Franny Scoville Barry Shabaka Henley as Blanche Bruce Nicholas Woodeson as Loeffler Christine Grace Szarko as Dr. Susan Edson Tim Otis as NY Reporter Željko Ivanek as Doctor Willard Bliss Richard Rankin as Alexander Graham Bell Kyle Soller as Robert Todd Lincoln Shaun Parkes as Dr. Charles Purvis Guy Roberts as Sgt. Mason Brendan Douglas as Judge Robertson Alena Doláková as Milly the Hooker Kristóf Widder as Service Worker Michael Pitthan as State Senator Murtha Scott Alexander Young as Priest Matt Devere as Ticket Agent John Poston as Depew Jeremy Wheeler as Reverend Hicks Marc Cram as NY Senate Chair Ralph Berkin as Lapham Sam Bell as Sarah the Attendant Josh Morrison as Dr. Lamb Luckas Urtubey as Delmonico's Reporter Declan Hannigan as Kearney Patricia McCullough as Reverend Power
