Guest Stars Beau Bridges as Howard "Senior" Markston Marnee Carpenter as Ellie Kingston Justina Machado as Eva Muñoz Bella Ortiz as Claudia Marlene Forte as Sister Louise Co Starring Eddie Mills as Rob Davis Joe Corzo as AJ Maree Cheatham as Sister Peggy Alex Borlo as Tanya Phil Buckman as Father Patrick Cassidy Cory Blevins as Michael Ross Danielle Hoetmer as Joy Suttonby Melissa Alce as Sister Bennie Jaxy Boyd as Judge Tracy Holden Whitney Bacon as Alyssa Lombardi
