Guest Stars Taylor Anthony Miller as Kelly Moran Vedette Lim as Elise Taylor James Chen as Ian Lim Mara Davi as Samantha Kelton Caleb Reese Paul as Tyler Kelton Adrian Alvarado as ATF Agent Sanchez Josh Meyers as Simon Ford LeRoy McClain as Baker McCaffrey Samuel Dunning as Third Testament Acolyte Co Starring Reagan Shumate as Kylie Sietzka Rose as Plastic Surgeon Sam Simone as Port Authority Officer #1 Michael Worden as Adam Grant Carol Todd as NYPD Commissioner Gates Grayson DeJesus as Trauma Surgeon Jake Eavey as Passenger Kev Morris Sr. as NYPD Officer #1 Erin Bradford as ER Nurse Angelo Maldonado Jr as Santa J. Zane Stephens as Chip McCaffrey Roy Scandela as Eric Samuels Misha Molani as NYPD Officer #2 Eliza Dewhirst Kingsbury as Pedestrian Credit Only Thomas Philip O'Neill as M.E. Dr. Neil Mosbach Suzy Jane Hunt as Janice Stroud Dave Register as Brandon Kraczuk Clinton Brandhagen as Warren Stroud
