Guest Stars James Marsters as First Evil Sarah Michelle Gellar as First Evil Adam Busch as First Evil Danny Strong as First Evil Danny Strong as Jonathan Levinson Tom Lenk as Andrew Wells Adam Busch as Warren Meers D.B. Woodside as Principal Robin Wood Harris Yulin as Quentin Travers Oliver Muirhead as Phillip Cynthia LaMontagne as Lydia Kris Iyer as Nigel Co Starring Camden Toy as Ubervamp Bobby Brewer as Hoffman Donald Bishop as Butcher Roberto Santos as Grimes
