Special Guest Stars Anthony Stewart Head as Rupert Giles Eliza Dushku as Faith Lehane Nathan Fillion as Caleb Guest Stars David Boreanaz as Angel Nathan Fillion as First Evil Sarah Michelle Gellar as First Evil Tom Lenk as Andrew Wells D.B. Woodside as Principal Robin Wood Iyari Limon as Kennedy Sarah Hagan as Amanda Indigo as Rona Co Starring Felicia Day as Vi Mary Wilcher as Shannon Lisa Ann Cabasa as Injured Girl Julia Ling as Potential with Power #2 Demetra Raven as Girl at Bat Katie Gray as Indian Girl Ally Matsumura as Japanese Girl Kelli Wheeler as School Girl Jenna Edwards as Trailer Girl
