Guest Stars Emily Marie Palmer as Sister Isabella Kate Forbes as Mrs. Olivia Fairfax Bill Heck as Philip Starks Christopher Cassarino as The Man / Booth Lauren Lee Denham as Lily Kevin Patrick Murphy as Soldier Finnigan Donny Boaz as Ezekial Davis Daniel Romer as Cyrus Davis Thomas Blake, Jr. as Soldier #2 Gretchen Koerner as Miss Evans Justin Geer as Wounded Soldier Scott Thomas as Soldier #1 Kate Leek as Prostitute Zackery Phillip Roundy as Hiram Davis Mathias Alvarez as Mounted Union Soldier David Pittu as Inspector Mussey Anthony Reynolds as Lead Soldier