Guest Stars Steven R. Schirripa as Anthony Abetemarco Brandhyze Stanley as Grace Michaels Malik Yoba as Det. Darryl Reid Joel de la Fuente as Edward Gomez William Popp as Marcus Donovan Philip Hernández as Reuben Tavares Andrew Hovelson as Chris Frye Sam Gilroy as David Gore Lilla Crawford as Lily Coleman Olivia Wang as Rita Isaiah Negrón as Tommy