Guest Stars Sprague Grayden as Meg Collins Nate Mooney as Connor O'Brien Larry Clarke as Father Kendellen Frank John Hughes as Detective Moreland Co Starring Ryan Bailey as Clerk Rob Roy Cesar as Reporter #2 Leah Allers as Reporter #1 Debra Leigh as Parishioner Randon Davitt as Young Connor Jennifer Cortese as Library Mother Natalie Brooke Edwards as Tara Kelly David Landry as Paul Collins Shane Zeranski as Looky-Lou Dwayne Standridge as Layperson #1 Dan Mailley as Salesman Curtis Fortier as Layperson #2 Brantley M. Dunaway as Officer Gardella Anna Clark as Sophia Collins Sean Patrick Murphy as Officer Liddy Timothy Brennen as Billy O'Brien
