Special Guest Stars Jimmy Fallon as Himself Betty White as Herself Jeff Dunham voices Pumpkin Jeff Dunham as Rick Wayne Guest Stars John Lutz as J.D. Lutz Sue Galloway as Sue LaRoche-Van der Hout Blaine Horton as Sacha Jonathan Dickson as Male Newscaster Nick Sullivan as Emcee Carson Elrod as Travis Melissa Wood as Attractive Woman Uncredited Jack McBrayer as Male Audience Member Jack McBrayer as Female Audience Member