Guest Stars Charlie Carver as Porter Scavo Joshua Logan Moore as Parker Scavo Max Carver as Preston Scavo Kathryn Joosten as Karen McCluskey Kendall Applegate as Penny Scavo David Starzyk as Bradley Scott Ion Overman as Maria Scott Christopher Rich as Bruce Megan Hilty as Shayla Grove Don Moss as Father Drance Co Starring John Ciccolini as Man in Pizzeria