Guest Stars Ernest Adams as Eddie Malia Pyles as Sarah Baskets Sabina Sciubba as Penelope Julia Rose as Crystal Baskets Ellen D. Williams as Nicole Maree Cheatham as Maggie David Hornsby as Pastor Ivy Jones as Grandma John O'Leary as Elderly Man Dan Cole as Middle Aged Guy Annie McKnight as Waitress Eve Brenner as Martha's Mother R.J. Walker as Chef Rose Castelli as Student #2 Mikel Chase as Radio DJ Sherry Mandujano as Concierge Logan John Shaefer as Easter Egg Boy Jeff Davis voices Neil Diamond Pierson Ryan as Student #1 Frank Noon as Usher Roger V. Burton as Martha's Father Reggie De Leon as Student #3 Mandy McMillian as Hostess Uncredited Zach Galifianakis as Dale Baskets
