Guest Stars Michelle Nolden as AUSA Robin Brooks David Gallagher as Buck Winters Andre Royo as Tim Pynchon Gary Basaraba as Joe Thibodeaux Paul Hipp as Gray McClaughlin Jamie Starr as Toby Rusty Schwimmer as Deanne Drake Co Starring Quinn Sullivan as Second Marshal Adam Dunnells as Rafe Lanksy Michael Li Paz as Rabbi