Guest Stars Jason Ritter as Mark Cyr Rosa Salazar as Zoe DeHaven Jonathan Tucker as Bob Little John Corbett as Seth Holt Courtney Ford as Lily Hayden Byerly as Micah Watson Cory Blevins as Doug Watson Melissa Greenspan as Val Watson Van Epperson as Pharmacist Abby Bankston as Team Captain #2 Skyler James as Team Captain #1 Antonio Gómez as Louis Fuentes Yvonne Huff as PE Teacher Jacklyn Hernandez as Liz