Guest Stars Aaron Abrams as Matthew Weitz François Arnaud as Oscar Trieste Kelly Dunn as Allison Knight Jordana Spiro as Sarah Weller Jay O. Sanders as Bill Weller Joe Dinicol as David Wagner Eisa Davis as Alexandra Harrison Max Darwin as Barkeeper David Alan Basche as Patrick Lyman Clem Cheung as Pit Boss David Aaron Baker as Mark Waterman Co Starring Erinn Ruth as Agent Rose Logan Smith as Sawyer Weller Mike Masters as Dennis Tristao Darius as Waiter John Dinello as Super