Guest Stars Andi Dorfman as Herself (The Bachelorette) Nick Viall as Nick Viall Josh Murray as Josh Murray Chris Soules as Chris Soules Andrew Poole as Andrew Poole Cody Sattler as Cody Sattler Dylan Pettit as Dylan Pettit J.J. O'Brien as J.J. O'Brien Marcus Grodd as Marcus Grodd Marquel Martin as Marquel Martin Patrick Jagodzinski as Patrick Jagodzinski Brian Osborne as Brian Osborne