Guest Stars Aisha Tyler as Dr. Tara Elisabeth Lewis Josh Stewart as Detective William LaMontagne Jr. Bodhi Elfman as Peter Lewis Sheryl Lee Ralph as Hayden Montgomery Frances Fisher as Antonia Slade Matt Battaglia as Captain Grant Howard James Shanklin as Timothy Ritchie Patrick Bristow as Asher Douglas Co Starring David L.M. McIntyre as Leonard Ennis Rif Hutton as Warden Bryan Nabb Travis Johns as Johnson Jonathan Camp as Eric Rawdon Michael James Lazar as Guard #1 David Patykewich as Spooky Prisoner