Special Guest Stars Danny Pino as Scotty Valens Guest Stars Robert Joy as Dr. Sid Hammerback A.J. Buckley as Adam Ross Mykelti Williamson as Chief Brigham Sinclair Carmen Argenziano as Insp. Stanton Gerrard Joey Lawrence as Clay Dobson John Patrick Amedori as T.J. Lindmark Bruce Nozick as Gene Hartley Casey Adams as Toby Finch Annika Peterson as Mindy Sanchez Sandra Nelson as Marilyn Bennett Co Starring Brenna Radding as Young Stella Bonasera Cait Fairbanks as 14 year old Mindy Mel Fair as Reporter #1 Baelyn Neff as Jessica Simms Miles Williams as Altar Boy #1 Brian D'Addario as Altar Boy #2 Ijeoma Njaka as Reporter #2