Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Abigail Hawk as Det. Abigail Baker Gregory Jbara as DCPI Garrett Moore Sami Gayle as Nicole "Nicky" Reagan-Boyle Tony Terraciano as Jack Reagan Nicholas Turturro as Sgt. Anthony Renzulli James Nuciforo as Jim Nuciforo Rory Duffy as Officer Calica David Ramsey as Mayor Carter Poole Wrenn Schmidt as Anna Goodwin Connor Gibbons as Patrick Leo Fitzpatrick as Leo Packer Rodrigo Lopresti as Keith Daley Lindsay Torrey as Robin Co Starring Mike Houston as Officer Calica John Rue as Chief of D's Ed Hines Peter Bockman as Priest Blanchard Ryan as Female Reporter Larry Pine as NYPD Chief Surgeon Stewart J. Zully as Under Secretary Price Aisha de Haas as Traffic Agent Barbara Galella as Parishioner #1 Joe Lisi as NYPD Chief of Counterterrorism Joseph A. Testa as Parishioner #2 Karen Ludwig as Leslie - Keith's mom Theresa Quadorozzi as Reporter #2 David Fonteno as NYPD Chief of Intel