Guest Stars Kathleen Munroe as Brenda MacDowell (2007 / 2008) Jeff Hephner as David Nelson Damon Herriman as John Smith (2008) Kevin Cooney as Deputy Sheriff Ted Huffard Jayne Taini as Dotty Phillips Co Starring Stevie Johnson as Newark Resident Jonathan Strait as Colleen's Husband Kincaid Walker as Hot Woman (2007) Sunil Malhotra as Cocky Dude (2007) Annie Abrams as Monica Capcot (2004) Eileen Grubba as Colleen (2006 / 2007) Shelby Zemanek as Brenda Age 6 Field Cate as John Smith (1983) Zone as Dreadlocks Michael Proctor as Male Party Guest Kristen Faye Hunter as Young Woman (1983)
