Guest Stars Chris Butler as Matan Brody Nicole Roderick as Nora Marc Warren as Nick Saverese Amanda Peet as Laura Hellinger Jane Alexander as Judge Suzanne Morris P.J. Brown as Bill Becky Ann Baker as Alma Hoff Stephen Root as Judge Murphy Wicks Robin Lord Taylor as Brock Reed Birney as Lee Hamish Linklater as David LaGuardia Phil McGlaston as Chicago Jury Foreman Bret Lada as Troy Dashiell Eaves as Tom Vanessa Wasche as Receptionist Patch Darragh as Brandt Jeff Wincott as Tim