Guest Stars Aaron Hill as Walter "Beaver" Boudreaux Johanna Braddy as Jordan Reed Michael Rady as Max Tyler Jesse McCartney as Andy Kristen O'Meara as Sheila Patty McCormack as Joan Co Starring Aynsley Bubbico as Laura Steffany Huckaby as Beth Gregory Hoyt as The Ref / Umpire / Official Samantha Figura as Andrea Uncredited Kristopher Hatfield as Jeremy