Special Guest Stars Susan Sarandon as Alicia Green Guest Stars Charles Durning as Michael Gavin Robert John Burke as Father Mickey Gavin Tatum O'Neal as Maggie Gavin Co Starring Natalie Distler as Colleen Gavin Olivia Crocicchia as Katy Gavin Peggy J. Scott as Jeannie Reilly Michael Zegen as Damian O'Keefe Alexa Havins as The Talker Brian d'Arcy James as Dr. Felcher Jay Wilkison as Hank Charity Henson as Nurse Francesca Cecil as Mike's Date