Special Guest Stars Naveen Andrews as Detective Ash Ramsey Sarah Paulson as Anne Gillette Edward Hibbert as Nigel Prestwick Guest Stars John Schuck as Chief of Detectives Muldrew Jabari Gray as CSU Tech Keegan Timmons Valerie Cruz as U.S. Attorney Camilla Velez Dennis Boutsikaris as Nate Hartman Nathan Lee Graham as Boutique Owner Liam Ferguson as Detective Mark La Mura as Jeweler Mark Havlis as Funeral Director Stuart Burney as Yancey Winthrop Robert Langdon Lloyd as Reverend Fitzgerald Kelly Karavites as Detective Eddie Noone as Detective Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration