Guest Stars Ana Gasteyer as Sheila Shay Chris Parnell as Frederick "Fred" Shay Parker Young as Ryan Shay Gillian Vigman as Jill Werner Jay Mohr as Steven Royce Courtney Merritt as Jenna Werner Gloria Votsis as Zoe Mo Collins as Trish Shay Jeremy Howard as Jasper Co Starring Evan Arnold as Chef Alan Dan Sachoff as Gary Shay Bambadjan Bamba as Street Vendor Madison Carlon as Meredith Shay Madeleine Claire as Shay Niece #2 Bellah Crawford as Shay Niece #1