Guest Stars Ana Gasteyer as Sheila Shay Chris Parnell as Frederick "Fred" Shay Jay Mohr as Steven Royce Todd Sherry as Tom Thomas McDonell as Scott Strauss Alex Boling as Alex Co Starring Katelyn Pacitto as Kaitlyn Kara Pacitto as Kenzie Evan Arnold as Chef Alan Patrick Rafferty as Chiropractor Jacqui Holland as Candy Anastacia Rose as Bambi