Guest Stars Maestro Harrell as Malik Parker Young as Ryan Shay Abbie Cobb as Kimantha Evan Arnold as Chef Alan Natalija Nogulich as Marcheeza Rachel Dratch as Paula Weingelb Co Starring Katelyn Pacitto as Kaitlyn Kara Pacitto as Kenzie Tiffany Martin as Young Paula Billy Marquart as Bartender Frances Mary McKittrick as Young Sheila