Guest Stars Raúl Esparza as Rafael Barba Joel Brady as Police Officer Lindsay Pulsipher as Kim Rollins Tyree Simpson as Desk Sergeant Frank Deal as FBI Agent O'Connell Kate Rogal as Katrine Kearns Theis Weckesser as Jeff Parker Taylor Spreitler as Taylor Culphers Catherine Missal as Emily Chris Coy as Peter Izzie Steele as Wendy Davis David Deblinger as Liza's Father Neal Matarazzo as Mr. Culphers Katie Chonacas as Misty Day Ean Sheehy as Job Jay Devore as Merc Suzanne H. Smart as Mrs. Fleiss Kathleen McCafferty as Liz Culphers Kathryn Markey as Ellen Kalreiss Michaela McPherson as Ashley Kalreiss Brandon Tyler Harris as Chaz David Raymond Wagner as Bob Contino Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration