Special Guest Stars Donal Logue as Captain Declan Murphy Guest Stars B.D. Wong as Dr. George Huang Laura Benanti as Maria Grazie Nia Vardalos as Counselor Minonna Efron Joshua Malina as Simon Wilkes Sharon Washington as Judge Hayes Kate Blumberg as Mrs. Wilkes Brian Baumgartner as Gordon Montlieff Welker White as Paula Walker Co Starring Stephen C. Bradbury as Judge Colin McNamara Anne Carney as Jury Foreperson Alison Fernandez as Zara Amaro Kimiko Glenn as Lily Deng Rory Duffy as Uni #2 Diomargy Nuñez as Uni #3 Jason Iannacone as Uni #1 Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration