Guest Stars Joe E. Tata as Nat Bussichio Kathleen Robertson as Clare Arnold Ann Gillespie as Jackie Taylor Matthew Laurance as Mel Silver Jeffrey King as Charley Rawlins James C. Victor as Peter Tucker Gregg Daniel as Dean Whitmore David Bowe as Garrett Slan / Warren Natalie Venetia Belcon as Janice Williams Tracy Fraim as Lenny Zeminski Miranda Viscoli as Amy Co Starring Paige Kettner as Erin Silver Ryanne Kettner as Erin Silver Maya Goodwin as Student Paul Witten as Bartender Giulietta Hill as Patricia John McLoughlin as Heckler Bill Dunleavy as Lt. Smith