Guest Stars Raymond J. Barry as Arlo Givens Jeremy Davies as Dickie Bennett Kaitlyn Dever as Loretta McCready Joseph Lyle Taylor as Doyle Bennett Peter Murnik as Trooper Tom Bergen Margo Martindale as Mags Bennett Linda Gehringer as Helen Givens Brad William Henke as Coover Bennett Rebecca Creskoff as Carol Johnson Tara Buck as Sally Peener Co Starring William Gregory Lee as Deputy Nick Mooney Allen Cutler as Billy Blake Darin Toonder as EMT Rolando Boyce as Reginald Eames Penny L. Moore as Protestor #1 Timothy Brennen as Protestor #2 Trevor Trout as Kid at Batting Cage