Special Guest Stars Ann-Margret as Margot Wilton Guest Stars Jorja Fox as Sara Sidle Larry Mitchell as Officer Mitchell Larry Sullivan as Officer Akers Mitchell Fink as Paramedic Fink Emily Skinner as Alise Jones Laurie Fortier as Carrie Jones David Julian Hirsh as Jason Jones Bryce Robinson as Robbie Wilton Kris Lemche as Joey Daniel Browning Smith as Sqweegel Co Starring Anne Leighton as Younger Margot Jaime Alvarez as Car Wash Valet